Below Zero. Behold the power of the BHAG.

Check back here for a one-a-day series of actions and solutions from now until 12/11.

A BHAG is a Big, Hairy Audacious Goal (pronounced “bee-hag”)  Pretty great, right?  Read on for Central Baptist Church’s story of dropping BELOW zero, including member transportation to and from church.  There are a few links to previous stories here, and we hope to have some more pictures and some follow up pieces as time marches on, but this story just couldn’t wait any longer.

207826_214699188546806_5287405_nGetting To Zero (CO2 Emissions) at Central Baptist Church

Summary: On Sunday, October 11, 2015, Central Baptist Church (CBC) in Wayne, PA, celebrated achieving “minus Zero” in its Getting to Zero campaign to reduce congregational carbon emissions.  The campaign was designed and conducted by the Ecology Mission Group (EMG) at CBC.

Chuck sells LED'15w

Chuck Marshall selling an LED as part of the CBC Ecology Mission Team.

  CBC’s EMG decided to offset its CO2 emissions several years ago, and focused at first on offsetting emissions from the operation of the building; i.e., the emissions from the use of electricity and natural gas, which the EMG estimated to total 41,000 pounds per year. The EMG developed three programs, described below, to offset these emissions:  solar panels, light bulbs, and wind energy. 

After these programs brought building use to carbon neutral in 2014, the EMG realized that an even greater carbon footprint than building use was probably congregational travel.  During 2015 the Getting to Zero campaign encouraged families to estimate and then to purchase offsets to their own CBC-related travel.  With help from the congregation, EMG estimated these emissions at 66,000 pounds per year. Over the summer of 2015, more than enough offsets were purchased to declare the congregation “minus Zero”.

central baptist church, wayne rooftop solarDetails: To offset the building emissions, CBC has three programs. One is a set of 48 solar panels installed on the flat roof of a wing of the church building. The panels were started in May 2009 and, since then approximately 71,000 Kwh of electricity have been generated. This is only an offset program because it lowers the electricity that CBC purchases from PECO. CBC does not count as offsets the Solar Renewable Energy Credits (SRECs) it receives and sells, because the sale of the credits allows someone else to emit carbon dioxide.  

CBC also offsets building operation CO2 emissions through a program called Bright Idea under which CBC yearly gives approximately 800 compact fluorescent bulbs (CFLs) and light-emitting diodes (LEDs) to social centers which then give the CFLs and LEDs to their clients to install in their homes or apartments. Based upon a survey done of the hours that the replaced bulbs operated, those emission offsets amount to 7,800 lbs. per year.

CBC also purchases wind energy from a supplier for 100 percent of its electricity use. The amount of electric consumption is metered after the solar panel electricity is used within the church or the excess is placed on the grid. Between Bright Idea and the purchase of wind energy, CBC offsets all of its emissions from the burning of natural gas and the electricity used.

How they got there: celebration display!

How they got there: celebration display!

It also occurred to the EMG that a lot of people drive vehicles to church every Sunday and that there are a lot of trips to church for meetings during the week, a lot of staff trips to and from church and several members and the pastors take long distance trips to Baptist board meetings and other conferences and events. The EMG felt that these CO2 emissions be counted also as an effect of operating a church. In fact, EMG did a gross estimate of these emissions and they were at 66,000 lbs. per year while the emissions from the electricity and gas were 41,000 lbs. The EMG also decided to find an emission factor for paper as a proxy for all of the emissions from the purchasing of products that support the worship services and communicate with members, like paper. The emission rate found for paper manufacturing was 27.5 lbs. of CO2 per ream of paper for 112 reams per year.

Having determined that travel-related emissions exceeded all other emissions, CBC decided to embark on a program called Getting To Zero. Each person or family unit was asked to complete a form that would result in an emissions figure for their church-related travel. More than one-half the people did not complete their form but gave the committee permission to fill it out for them. This detailed emission inventory was very close to the gross estimate of emissions made for CBC. The range of CO2 emissions for most people/families was from about 100 lbs. per year up to 2200 lbs. per year. The staff emissions were from 800 lbs. per year up to about 3500 lbs. Next, the committee produced the table shown below as Table 2 and a set of instructions that help individuals and families chose how to offset their emissions. Not going to church was not offered or encouraged. The choices were installing LEDs or CFLs, buying wind energy from a supplier, or any other option the family/person could choose (e.g., geothermal energy).

CBC children made a giant ZERO to parade with in the sanctuary in celebration!

CBC children made a giant ZERO to parade with in the sanctuary in celebration!

The options have subtle differences. For example, the tree plantings must be done every year while the LED lights offsets occur for as long as the bulbs are used. The option chosen the most was tree planting. We are working with a non-profit organization called Trees, Water, People in Fort Collins, Colorado.   The cost only amounts to $1 per ton of offset which we will pay for each year. The organization is not certified for their tree plantings because of the large cost it would take for a relatively small non-profit to become internationally certified. TWP plants trees in several counties, one of which is El Salvador. CBC has a sister church, Shekina, in Santa Anna, about 12 miles from one of TWP’s tree nurseries and forests.

CBC estimates that for the first year of this program, the baseline CO2 emissions of 108,000 pounds per year have been exceeded by the offsets of 123,000 pounds of carbon dioxide; getting to minus zero.

Table 1. Estimated CBC Carbon Dioxide Emissions

Source Category Algorithm CO2 Emissions Rate Emissions of CO2 Source of Data and Comments
Electricity 36,000 kwh per year (PECO bills) 0.44548 Kg CO2 per kwh 16,037 kg*2.214 lbs=35,507 2012 EPA data.
Natural Gas 6228 CCF gas consumed per year (PECO bills) 0.1848 Kg CO2/ccf 2548 lbs. + 876 for mission house= 3424 2012 data. AP-42 shows 0.12 lbs per ccf.
Paper purchases #reams = 135. *3 pages/copy*54 services=44 reams plus 20 newslttrs *5 sheets*50 copies = 10.0 reams plus copies of 2 reams per week * 52 weeks 12.5 Kg CO2/ream of paper = 112*12.5 kg*2.2 lbs per Kg 3080 pounds CO2 per year Paper industry website
Travel To and Fro
   Staff 3 cars *5 days/wk*48 weeks * 10 miles/trip = 7200 miles/yr 0.260585 Kg CO2e/mile 4154 pounds CO2 per year
   Sunday 110 people/wk/1.5 families per car= 73.3 trips*48 wks*20 miles/trip- 70,368 miles 0.260585 Kg CO2/mile 40,598 pounds CO2 per year
   Weekday mtgs. 50% of Sunday 20,299 Assumption

                                                                                 Grand total           107,886 lbs. CO2 per year

The summary of carbon dioxide emissions by category is as follows.

Electricity Consumption                                33.2 percent
Natural Gas Consumption                             3.2
Operations as rep. by paper reams             2.8
Staff travel to CBC                                           3.8
Sunday roundtrips                                          38.0
Weekday trips to CBC                                   ­­  19.0__
Total                                                                  100.0

Table 2. Carbon Dioxide Offset Options for CBC Members

(Lbs./yr) CO2                         KWH/Yr                           LED Lights                         Trees to Have
Emissions                            To Offset                         To Install                          Planted

100 71 1 1
200 143 2 1
400 286 3 2
600 429 4 3
800 571  5 4
1000 714 6 5
1200